The Two State Solution Is Dead

UPDATE 10 am Israel time Friday:

Two mortars were fired into southern Israel by Palestinian terrorists in Gaza at 2 am this morning.

You will recall a previous israelstreet blog this month about the outpouring of support for Israel in Stockholm, Sweden. This morning a bomb rocked a Jewish congregation building in Malmo.

Your humble servant has little to add about PM Netanyahu’s speech at the United Nations last night. It was a straightforward presentation of the facts that left no doubt, literally, about where Israel’s red line is–though there has been serious misreportage about where Netanyahu said that red line is. Here are his words:

“By next spring, at most by next summer at current enrichment rates, they will have finished the medium enrichment and moved on to the final stage. . . The red line should be drawn right here [Netanyahu draws the line with a red marker] before Iran completes the second stage of nuclear enrichment necessary to make a bomb.” 

Note that Netanyahu said that action must be taken “before” Iran completes the second stage–“before” the Spring or summer of next year.


A map used by the PLO/PA in Palestinian schools. Is anything missing?

The two state solution as conceived by the “peacemakers” in the West is dead.

The truth, as noted in yesterday’s blog, is that it was never alive. From the moment that the Palestinian Arab community rejected the Peel Commission report in 1937 which sought to create an “Arab Palestine” and a “Jewish Palestine” until Mahmoud Abbas’ speech last night at the United Nations, the Palestinians have rejected every attempt to create a Palestinian state and every offer of peace ever made by Israel.

The Palestinians rejected a Palestinian state in 1947 when one was handed to them by the United Nations. The Palestinians rejected a Palestinian state from 1948-1967 when Arabs controlled the “West Bank” area the Palestinians claim to want now. The Palestinians rejected a Palestinian state offered by Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin in the 1993 Oslo Accords. The Palestinians rejected a Palestinian state in a peace deal offered by Israeli PM Ehud Barak in 2000. The Palestinians rejected a Palestinian state offered by Israeli PM Ehud Olmert in 2007.

Why have the Palestinians rejected every offer of peace and every effort to create a Palestinian state west of the Jordan River?  Simply because the Palestinians want all of the land west of the Jordan River–every inch of it.

Last night, Mahmoud Abbas was introduced to the United Nations as the “Chairman of the Palestinian Liberation Organization”. Lest we forget, the Palestinian Liberation Organization was founded in 1964–at a time when no one but Palestinians were living in the “West Bank”. What exactly was the PLO trying to liberate in 1964? There were none of  Mahmoud Abbas’ hated “settlers”, no “occupying Zionist forces”, no “Zionist communities.”  The PLO’s goal was, and always has been, the elimination of Israel–not the creation of a state of Palestine.

Abbas, the same man who has said that a future Palestine would not have a single Jew in it, began his speech in Orwellian fashion last night accusing Israel of ethnic cleansing, even though Israel has not deported even 1 Palestinian from Jerusalem, Judea, or Samaria–and the Palestinian population has steadily increased.  He continued by grotesquely asserting that the Palestinian terrorists in Israeli prisons are in reality “soldiers in their people’s struggle for freedom, independence, and peace.”

Abbas proceeded quickly to reject the absurd Western idea that the Palestinians would agree to any future peace plan that would divide Judea and Samaria such as plan dredged up again by Ehud Barak this week:

“My people will continue their epic steadfastness and eternal survival in their beloved land, every inch of which carries the evidence and landmarks affirming their roots and unique connection throughout ancient history.” 

Epic steadfastness? Eternal survival? Ancient history? The only epic, eternal, and ancient history that the Palestinians have is what they have attempted to steal from the Jews.

Abbas then proceeded to reject any peace plan that does not involve returning all of the so-called “Palestinian refugees” to Israel–a return that would destroy the country of Israel:

“The core components of a just solution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict do not require effort to discover, but rather what is needed is the will to implement them . . . This includes the realization of the independence of the State of Palestine, with East Jerusalem as its capital, over the entire territory occupied by Israel since 1967, and the realization of a just, agreed solution to the Palestine refugee issue in accordance with resolution 194, as prescribed in the Arab Peace Initiative.

What Abbas and the PLO want is what they have always wanted–to set up a temporary Palestinian state in the territory captured by Israel in 1967 and then flood Israel with some 5,000,000 Palestinian refugees (Resolution 194 as understood by the Arab world) thereby eliminating Israel as a Jewish state and transforming it into an Arab Palestine.

Speaking of a Jewish state, you will remember the Dershowitz formula from yesterday. Abbas had supposedly agreed to begin negotiations with Israel based on a “conditional freeze” of Israeli construction of homes, schools, and hospitals in Judea and Samaria. Part of this signage was to have been a direct statement in Abbas’ speech last night “linking” “Judaism” with Israel.

Abbas did not utter the words “Jew”, “Jewish”, or “Judaism.”

But he did mention “Israel” or “Israeli” –33 times. You can get a flavor how they were used by the first few references: “racist Israeli settlement of our country Palestine”, “terrorist militias of Israeli settlers”, “killing and abuse with complete collusion of occupying forces and the Israeli government”, “a culture of incitement in the Israeli curriculum and extremist declarations”, “Israel the occupying Power”, “prisoners and detainees in Israel’s jails”, “Israeli occupying forces demolished” . . .

In the end, Abbas brazenly accused Israel of being on the verge of instigating a “second Nakba” (despite the myriad of concessions that Israel has made in recent months to keep the PLO/PA afloat)–and called on the United Nations to not allow it. As Israeli FM Lieberman said this morning, it was a speech filled with nothing except incitement against Israel–the same incitement we Israelis have heard for the last 64 years. 

The two state solution of an Israeli state and a Palestinian state wholly west of the Jordan River was such a lovely idea. Two peoples living together on the same land and sharing the same aspiration for peace. Two peoples bound together by religion, history and place learning to respect each other and embrace each other’s differences. Two peoples pooling their resources and talents to create an oasis of coexistence in the Middle East.

It is a Western idea rooted in the absurd notion that, at heart, everyone is the same–everyone wants what everyone else wants, and if we just talk long enough about the problem it will eventually go away and be solved. It is a total delusion.

As noted Israeli historian Benny Morris observed in the interview I quoted yesterday: “[The] goals of the Palestinian national movement [are] to extinguish the Jewish national project and to inherit all of Palestine for the Arabs and Islam.”

Tomorrow, unless events intervene, your humble servant will discuss where we go from here.

A daily feature of this blog is the recognition of those of you who support Israel by donating to this website. Each month, your humble servant places each name on this wall of support into the Western Wall in Jerusalem. Today we are highlighting “Chen” from Singapore, and “Hong-bin” from Seoul.

To have your own Israeli flag, simply follow two steps:

Step 1: Click on the “Support Israel Street! Donate” button in the right hand column and submit your information.

Step 2: Send an email to with the following information:

Your name (or location):

The donation that you made (for purposes of identifying you):

A. A donation of $10 puts your flag on this website for one month

B. A donation of $20 puts your flag on this website for two months

C. A donation of $30 puts your flag on this website for three months

D. A donation of $100 or more puts your flag on this website for a year

What you want on your flag :


This entry was posted in News and tagged 145000000, 1937, 1947, 1964, 64 years, absurd notion, ancient history, arab palestine, arabs and islam, aspiration for peace, Barak, before iran completes the second stage, benny morris, bomb, coexistence, concessions, conditional freeze, creation, dead, delusion, demolished, dershowitz, destroy, detainees, Egypt, epic, ethnic cleansing, every inch, every offer, everyone is the same, exploded, extinguish the jewish national project, flood, formula, freedom, future, Gaza, goal, history, incitement, independence, inherit all of palestine, iran, Israel, Israeli, isreal, Jerusalem, Jew, Jewish, jewish congregation, jewish palestine, jordan, jordan river, judaism, Judea, Lebanon, liberate, lieberman, living together, Malmo, middle east, militias, mortars, nakba, Netanyahu, nuclear enrichment, oasis, occupy, occupying forces, olmert, orwellian, oslo accords, palestine, Palestinian, palestinian national movement, Palestinian state, peace, peace deal, peace plan, peacemakers, peel commission, prisons, rabin, racist, red line, refugees, rejected, religion, resolution 194, Samaria, second, settlers, southern, state of israel, steadfast, steal from Jews, stockholm, Sweden, Syria, terrorists, two peoples, two state solution, two state solution is dead, united nations, west, west bank, western idea, zionists. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.