Adopting the J Street Position: Trump Breaks His Promise (Part 2)


J Street welcomes President Trump’s decision today to sign a presidential waiver to allow the US Embassy in Israel to remain in Tel Aviv.

This decision is in keeping with 20 years of bipartisan policy since the passage of the 1995 Jerusalem Embassy Act, which permits the president to continually waive, for a period of six months at a time, the act’s requirement that the US Embassy in Israel be moved to Jerusalem. Presidents Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama each issued such waivers every six months throughout their tenures.

J Street believes that Jerusalem is absolutely central to the history, culture and identity of the Jewish people. We look forward to it, one day, being recognized by the entire world as Israel’s capital, as part of a negotiated two-state solution. We agree with the policy of all Democratic and Republican presidents since 1967 who, while recognizing the deep and unbreakable Jewish connection to Jerusalem, have maintained the official position that the status of Jerusalem is to be decided by negotiations between the parties. American governments have avoided and objected to actions that could be interpreted as prejudging the outcome of those negotiations. The US therefore — like every other country with which Israel has bilateral relations — has its embassy in Tel Aviv, rather than in Jerusalem.

Since the disposition of Jerusalem is a final status issue that must be decided by the parties themselves, moving the embassy could cause significant harm to US credibility as a mediator in efforts to move toward a two-state peace agreement. Jordan and Egypt, countries that have made peace with Israel and who are eager to contribute to a reinvigorated Israeli-Palestinian peace process, have made clear their strong opposition to such a move.

Moving the embassy could also have a more immediate security impact. Even seemingly minor changes to Jerusalem’s status quo in fact or law have historically carried the risk of sparking potential violence.

We are glad that the administration has heeded the advice of veteran officials in the diplomatic and security communities, and decided to maintain the prudent policy of its predecessors on this issue.

Unfortunately, one cannot help but believe that this disgusting statement exactly summarizes President Trump’s attitude toward the issue:

1. President Trump undoubtedly listened to the “advice” of veteran officials in the diplomatic and security communities–mostly career functionaries in the State Department and the Defense Department who maintain an avowedly pro-Palestinian stance, but also Trump’s own innermost circle of advisers such as McMaster and Mattis (Mattis is on record saying that “Tel Aviv is the capital of Israel”).

2. President Trump undoubtedly bought into the Palestinian narrative that moving the Embassy would spark an explosion of violence in Israel and throughout the Arab world–as if there could be a bigger explosion than the ongoing one in Syria or those in Iraq and elsewhere. It is simply amazing how easily the international community is cowed by Palestinian threats.

3. President Trump undoubtedly bought into the ludicrous notion that Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia are eager for peace. Just yesterday, Jordan threatened Israel again because several hundred Jews went up to the Temple Mount on Shavuot. As for Egypt and Saudi Arabia, they are all for peace as long as 5,000,000+ self-proclaimed “Palestinian refugees” are resettled in Israel.

4. Most disastrously, President Trump has bought into the J Street, United Nations, European, and Palestinian belief that Jerusalem is not intrinsically Jewish–and that its status must be decided through negotiation.

What Trump and most people outside of Israel simply cannot understand is that when it comes to Jerusalem, there is nothing to negotiate.


One last thought: whatever happened to all of the people surrounding Trump who were supposed to be so pro-Israel: David Friedman, Ivanka Trump, Jared Kushner, etc. What did all of them have to say about Trump’s decision?

Absolutely nothing.

Silence is acquiescence.

This entry was posted in News and tagged broken promise, Israel, J Street, Jerusalem, negotiate, trump, waiver. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.